Nghipondoka defeats CPBN in N$479m rail tender dispute

Renthia Kaimbi

The Central Procurement Board of Namibia (CPBN) has suffered a legal setback in its battle to defend the award of a N$479 million railway tender to Luka Roads Rails and Civils CC and Voestalpine VAE SA.

The High Court dismissed its application to overturn a Review Panel decision in favour of rival bidder China Communications Construction Company Ltd JV Profile Investments (Pty) Ltd.

Namibian businessman Vaino Nghipondoka is the executive chairman of Profile Investments (Pty) Ltd.

In a judgment delivered on 13 November, Judge Nate Ndauendapo found that the procurement board had failed to comply with an earlier Review Panel order requiring it to re-evaluate Profile JV’s financial bid without treating the absence of financial statements audited by a Public Accountants’ and Auditors’ Board (PAAB)-registered auditor as grounds for automatic disqualification.

The court held that the Review Panel’s finding that the PAAB audit requirement was immaterial remained valid and binding because the board had never challenged it through judicial review.

The judgment effectively exposes the board’s handling of the tender to a fundamental legal problem that it continued to disqualify Profile JV on precisely the ground the Review Panel had already declared immaterial.

“The Board should not have disqualified Profile JV’s bid on the basis that their financial statements of two years were not audited by auditors registered with PAAB,” Ndauendapo ruled.

The court dismissed the review application brought by the board and Luka JV, ordering them to pay Profile JV’s legal costs jointly and severally, including the costs of one instructing and one instructed counsel.

The dispute centres on a tender advertised in September 2023 for the supply and delivery of rails, turnouts and stop blocks for the Northern Rail Extension Phase 3 between Ondangwa and Oshakati, as well as the upgrading of the Southern Railway Line between Sandverhaar and Buchholzbrunn.

The procurement, valued at an estimated N$479.4 million, attracted bids from several joint ventures, including Profile JV and Luka JV.

Profile JV’s bid was initially rejected after the Bid Evaluation Committee found that its financial statements for the 2020/2021 and 2021/2022 financial years had not been audited by auditors registered with PAAB.

The board also questioned Profile JV’s average current ratio, which it found fell below the required threshold of one when certain shareholder and group company loans were excluded.

However, the Review Panel repeatedly intervened after Profile JV challenged its disqualification, with the October 2024 decision becoming the turning point in the dispute.

On 4 October 2024, the Review Panel found that the board had acted inconsistently in evaluating Profile JV’s bid and specifically ruled that the requirement for its financial statements to be audited by a PAAB-registered auditor was not material.

It consequently ordered the board to re-evaluate Profile JV’s financial bid correctly and consistently in accordance with the bidding document.

But instead of treating the audit issue as immaterial, the board again declared Profile JV non-responsive, citing the same failure to submit PAAB-audited financial statements.

The board subsequently approved the award of the tender to Luka JV on 14 November 2024 and issued a notice of selection on 29 November.

Profile JV returned to the Review Panel, arguing that the board had disregarded its earlier ruling.

On 27 January 2025, the Review Panel found that the board had failed to comply with the October 2024 order and directed it to implement the ruling by re-evaluating Profile JV’s bid at the financial evaluation stage.

The board, however, approached the High Court to have the January 2025 decision reviewed and set aside, insisting that it had complied with the earlier order and was entitled to apply the financial requirements contained in the bidding document.

Luka JV subsequently applied to join the proceedings as a co-applicant, supporting the board’s position and seeking an order directing that the tender be awarded to it.

It argued that Profile JV had failed to meet the financial requirements, including the prescribed average current ratio, and that its bid price of N$415.8 million was approximately 13% below the estimated project cost, exceeding the permitted 10% deviation.

Luka JV further argued that the Review Panel could not use the principle of administrative regularity to effectively rewrite the bidding document or force the board to disregard mandatory procurement requirements.

However, the court found that the central issue was not whether the Review Panel had been correct in declaring the PAAB audit requirement immaterial, but whether its unchallenged decision remained legally binding on the board.

Ndauendapo relied on the legal principle established in the landmark Oudekraal judgment, which holds that an administrative decision, even if potentially unlawful, continues to have legal consequences until it is set aside by a competent court.

The judge found that the board had challenged the Review Panel’s January 2025 enforcement decision without challenging the underlying October 2024 ruling.

“The finding of immateriality had important consequences. Non-compliance could be overlooked,” the judge stated.

The court rejected Luka JV’s argument that the Review Panel’s finding was merely an incidental statement in its reasons and did not prevent the board from enforcing the bidding requirements.

Ndauendapo emphasised that the finding was a substantive determination by an administrative body and not a passing observation that the board could simply disregard.

“The statement is a finding by an administrative body (the Review Panel), and not a statement in passing,” the judgment reads.

The judge further found that the bidding document itself did not expressly state that failure to submit financial statements audited by a PAAB-registered auditor would automatically render a bid non-responsive.

This was significant because the same bidding document expressly identified other requirements whose non-compliance would result in disqualification.

The court consequently found that the board’s repeated reliance on the PAAB audit requirement to disqualify Profile JV demonstrated that it had not fully implemented the Review Panel’s October 2024 order.

Ndauendapo also rejected the board’s argument that it had complied with the order simply because it had instructed the Bid Evaluation Committee to conduct another assessment.

The judge said the board could not claim compliance while continuing to rely on the very requirement the Review Panel had declared immaterial.

“The finding of immateriality by the Review Panel appears to be based or from the bidding document itself,” the judgment states.

The board and Luka JV had also sought to persuade the court that the Review Panel’s decision could not override the board’s statutory procurement responsibilities.

However, the judge distinguished the present dispute from a recent Supreme Court decision involving the Namibia Competition Commission, where the Oudekraal principle was found not to validate an administrative resolution that effectively amended an Act of Parliament.

In this matter, the judge found that the Review Panel’s finding on the PAAB requirement did not amend legislation or confer legislative powers on the panel.

The court therefore concluded that the unchallenged October 2024 decision remained binding until set aside.

Having reached that conclusion, Ndauendapo said there was no need to determine the remaining disputes, including the arguments surrounding Profile JV’s financial ratios, the alleged price deviation and whether Luka JV should ultimately receive the contract.

Profile JV’s conditional counter-application, which sought to have Luka JV’s November 2024 award notice set aside if the board’s review succeeded, also fell away.

Although the court dismissed the board and Luka JV’s application, it did not directly award the tender to Profile JV or set aside Luka JV’s selection.

The judgment therefore leaves the tender’s ultimate award unresolved.

The matter was removed from the roll and regarded as finalised, with the board and Luka JV ordered to pay Profile JV’s costs jointly and severally.

Related Posts