OBSERVER FEATURE | Two private sectors, one country: Is Namibia’s banking system keeping economic racial divides alive?

Black entrepreneurs say they face a different set of rules when seeking finance. Banks insist lending is based on commercial risk. It is time for the banks to open their books and let the evidence speak.

Namibia prides itself on having a private sector that is central to economic growth, employment creation and national development. 

Yet, beneath the language of economic participation and entrepreneurship, an uncomfortable question persists: do we really have one integrated private sector, or are we operating two parallel economies, divided largely along racial and historical lines?

It is a question that deserves serious national attention, particularly as Namibia approaches four decades of independence.

There is a perception, widely expressed among black entrepreneurs, that the country’s private sector remains structurally divided.

On one side is a predominantly established, historically white-owned business community, with significant accumulated assets, established commercial relationships, access to capital and a degree of economic independence. 

On the other is an emerging black-owned business community, many of whose businesses remain smaller, undercapitalised and heavily dependent on government procurement, public-sector contracts and political or institutional opportunities to survive and grow.

This is a broad characterisation, not a description of every business.

There are successful black-owned companies operating independently of the government, just as there are white-owned businesses that depend on public contracts and face serious financial difficulties.

Nevertheless, the underlying question is whether historical inequalities continue to determine who gets to participate meaningfully in the economy and, more importantly, who gets to grow.

At the centre of this debate is the banking sector.

For many black entrepreneurs, access to finance remains one of the biggest obstacles to establishing, expanding and sustaining businesses.

The complaint is not necessarily that banks refuse to lend to black businesspeople altogether.

Rather, it is that the requirements, assessments, attitudes and commercial relationships governing access to finance appear to favour those who already possess wealth, property, established businesses and longstanding banking relationships.

The perception is that a white entrepreneur with an established balance sheet, property portfolio and business track record is more likely to secure a substantial loan than a black entrepreneur with a viable business proposition but limited collateral.

Are these perceptions justified? And, if they are, to what extent is the problem one of direct discriminatory practices, institutional culture or structural inequalities inherited from the past?

These are questions Namibia’s banking institutions can no longer simply dismiss.

Banks will understandably argue that lending decisions are based on risk, repayment capacity, collateral, cash flow and commercial viability, rather than race. These are legitimate considerations.

Banks are commercial institutions, not charitable organisations, and they have a responsibility to protect depositors’ money and maintain sound balance sheets.

But there is a fundamental problem with applying apparently race-neutral lending criteria in an economy where the distribution of wealth and assets was never historically equal.

Collateral is a particularly important example. Property ownership, commercial land, established businesses and accumulated assets are often the foundation upon which further wealth is built.

Entrepreneurs who inherited or accumulated assets over generations have a significant advantage over those entering the commercial economy without comparable financial foundations.

A bank may therefore apply exactly the same lending criteria to two entrepreneurs and still produce outcomes that reinforce existing economic inequalities.

This is where the debate becomes more complicated than simply accusing banks of racism. It is about whether the financial system adequately recognises the different starting positions of Namibians and whether it has developed innovative instruments to address those differences.

Being banked is not the same as being financed. Having a bank account does not mean having access to the capital required to build a manufacturing operation, acquire commercial property, purchase machinery, develop a tourism enterprise or expand an agricultural business.

The distinction matters enormously for small and medium enterprises, which are frequently identified as the engine of economic growth but remain among the most constrained when it comes to accessing affordable finance.

The question must also be asked about the composition of the banking sector itself. Are local banks sufficiently invested in developing a broader Namibian entrepreneurial class?

How many emerging black-owned businesses have graduated from small overdrafts and short-term facilities into substantial commercial financing?

What proportion of their lending goes to small and medium enterprises, and how much reaches businesses without substantial fixed-property collateral?

More importantly, do banks have measurable strategies to broaden economic ownership, or is financial inclusion largely confined to opening accounts and offering consumer lending?

It is time for Namibia’s banks to open their books.

We are not calling for the disclosure of individual customers’ confidential banking information or commercially sensitive details.

We are calling for meaningful, anonymised and independently verifiable lending data that allows the public to examine how credit is distributed across the economy.

Banks should disclose the number and value of commercial loan applications received, approved and rejected, broken down by business size, sector and ownership demographics.

They should reveal the average loan sizes, interest rates, collateral requirements, approval periods and reasons for rejection.

They should also indicate what proportion of their commercial lending reaches black-owned businesses, particularly small and medium enterprises.

Where appropriate safeguards are in place to protect customer privacy, this information should be published annually and made available to the Bank of Namibia and relevant policymakers.

If the banks are confident that their lending practices are fair and that commercial considerations, rather than racial preferences, determine their decisions, transparency should not be a threat. It should be an opportunity to demonstrate that confidence.

Conversely, if the data reveals significant disparities, Namibia will finally have an evidence base upon which to build corrective measures.

Silence and general assurances about transformation are not sufficient. The country deserves evidence.

However, the private sector must also confront another uncomfortable reality: the extent to which black-owned businesses have become dependent on the government.

Since independence, government procurement, public enterprises and state-supported economic programmes have created opportunities for black entrepreneurs. 

These interventions have played an important role in broadening participation in the economy.

But they have also contributed to a business environment in which some companies are built around securing government tenders rather than developing sustainable commercial models.

A business whose survival depends almost entirely on government contracts is vulnerable to delayed payments, changing political priorities, budget constraints and procurement disruptions. It is not truly independent.

This is not exclusively a black business problem. Established companies across Namibia also benefit from government contracts, public infrastructure expenditure and state-supported economic activity.

But the emerging black business sector must be particularly conscious of the danger of confusing access to tenders with the creation of lasting wealth.

There is a difference between owning a business and owning an economic asset.

Namibia needs more black-owned companies in mining, agriculture, manufacturing, logistics, tourism, commercial property, technology and financial services.

It needs businesses that own productive assets, employ people, develop intellectual property, export products and compete regionally and internationally without relying on the government to keep their doors open.

This requires a change in approach, including among black entrepreneurs themselves. Collaboration, pooled capital, joint ventures and commercially governed investment vehicles could create opportunities that individual entrepreneurs might struggle to finance independently.

Black-owned businesses must also move beyond competing for the same limited pool of government tenders and begin building enterprises capable of competing in the wider economy.

At the same time, the government cannot simply transfer responsibility for economic transformation to entrepreneurs.

It has a responsibility to create an enabling environment through appropriate legislation, effective development finance institutions, fair procurement practices, credit guarantees and mechanisms that encourage investment in viable businesses.

Banks, too, must recognise that economic development is not separate from their commercial interests. A larger, more diversified and financially empowered business community represents a larger market, more customers, more deposits and greater opportunities for lending.

There are lessons to be drawn from South Africa’s development finance experience, particularly the Industrial Development Corporation, which has supported industrialisation and business expansion through development-oriented financing.

Namibia does not necessarily need to replicate another country’s model, but it should seriously examine whether its own development finance institutions are adequately equipped and capitalised to support emerging enterprises.

Ultimately, the question of whether Namibia has two private sectors cannot be answered through political rhetoric or anecdotal complaints.

It requires evidence, transparency and an honest examination of how economic opportunity is distributed.

We cannot celebrate black economic empowerment while the ownership of productive assets remains concentrated.

Nor can we build a sustainable economy if an entire generation of entrepreneurs believes that the doors of commercial finance are effectively closed to them.

The challenge is therefore twofold: banks must demonstrate that their lending practices are fair, transparent and responsive to Namibia’s economic realities, while black entrepreneurs must take greater responsibility for building businesses that are commercially independent, financially disciplined and capable of creating lasting wealth.

Independence was meant to open economic opportunities for all Namibians. The private sector should be one of its greatest beneficiaries.

The uncomfortable question remains: have we built one integrated Namibian private sector, or have we simply inherited two economies operating under one flag?

And to Namibia’s banks, there is a simple challenge: if lending decisions are truly colour-blind, let us see the numbers. Open your books. Let the evidence speak.

Related Posts